The Quora website launched two years ago, collating questions-and-answers on a variety of topics and receiving favourable write-ups in the media.
It’s possible that you were one of the early sign-ups to the service, investigating whether you would find it useful, and don’t visit the site much very often. Or you could be one of the die-hard Quora lovers who still gets value out of the site’s community.
But there’s something that all Quora users should know.
Earlier this month, Quora made a decision which changes your privacy on the site. And they did it without asking your permission first.
They decided to introduce “Views” – functionality which creepily reveals to others the articles you have been reading.
In a trick presumably learnt from a chorus of other uncaring social networking sites, Quora has left it up to the user to turn off the “Views” feature (opt-out) rather than the much more privacy-friendly alternative of asking users to opt-in if they really want others to see what articles they have read.
As we’ve said many times before – if a feature really is a huge benefit to the user, why do websites have so little confidence that they can encourage users to opt-in rather than thinking it’s alright to reduce privacy without asking first?
Now, you may think – why would I care if people can see what questions I have read on Quora?
Well, here’s a few examples of the kind of things you could have read:
Still comfortable?
Sandra Liu Huang, a product manager at Quora, tried to justify why the site enabled the “Views” feature by default in a CNET interview:
"It will help writers get feedback to improve the content they write. If it were an opt-in product it wouldn't be as useful to writers because not enough people may go turn it on. It will improve the content and help readers discover useful and interesting content more quickly."
If you don’t like the idea of other people seeing what you are reading you have two options:
1) You can change your Quora account settings, by visiting Profile/Settings/Views and choosing “No”. (This is the option that Quora enabled without asking your permission)
2) Another option, of course, is to delete your account. Quora helpfully provides a Q&A about how to delete your Quora account.
At the time of writing, over 1800 people have read the deletion article.
What do you think about this new feature of Quora?
Was there a better way for Quora to introduce the technology?
Should people be concerned that it was turned on by default, or are we living in the dark ages by being worried about this kind of thing?
Leave a comment below and let us know your thoughts.
Follow @gcluley
Heh, and think that the list of people who read the “how to delete my account” article doesn’t include those who deleted it after reading it!
I just logged in to Quora to change the Views setting (I haven't logged in for many months) and it's set to "No". Perhaps they've changed it to opt-in?
It would be nice to think that they had changed their minds, but I don't believe they have.
I logged into Quora for the first time in many months as well this morning, and found the "Views" option was set to "yes". See the screenshot in the article.
And Quora themselves seem to be attempting to justify their decision. I can't explain why you have seen something different – maybe they haven't rolled it out to all users yet? Who can say..
I think Quora may have reversed this policy change, but I'm not certain. The fact that it wasn't communicated, in advance, that the change would be made, to implement the definitely CREEPY view tracking, was rather wrong, in my opinion.
The fact that, at the moment, four weeks later, I am still uncertain whether or not the tracking feature has been fully "redacted" or not is almost as troubling.
Thank you, Graham Cluley for this write up. I wish I had read this when you posted it, four weeks ago. You got to the point more quickly and clearly than articles I read elsewhere!
“Views” option? is that the screen block with all those squares that blocks the content of the emails, and the interesting topics? I don,t know why i keep getting generated emails, but there blocked every time?!! I would like the read and participate but it’s blocked?!! please let me know how to X out that screen?
That’s not what he’s talking about. You have to literally sign up (register) to read/ ask/ participate. If you click on a link that leads into Quora, yes, it is blocked. Quora is a bit…. strict… BUT! It is a progressive circlejerk there and since moderators are human — and have biases themselves — moderation is kind of useless. Many progressive Quorans operate on double-standards and mass upvote silly emotions over reason, specifically to “collapse” opposing viewpoints. Quora is probably the largest progressive echo-chamber in the universe….
I do like the echo chamber bit😊
I say, welcome to the Internet overall. You can't expect too much privacy on there. I can imagine Facebook going on the same route as the website Quora is doing right now. Granted, not that extreme, but it could still go with fairly concerning. That's just my opinion, though.
I am shocked that this was never submitted to reddit! The button in the left sidebar remains untouched. And redditors are so fond of Quora news.
:o)
Graham is thoughtful to have kept the comments open on this post, 533 days later.
I agree. What you do on Google is practically available to anyone wanting to advertise even those who want to data mine. What can they glean from you that Google can’t? (even this post!!)
apropos all this, having bought a Western Digital baby NAS unit (My Book Live) (a poor technical decision, in the event) I was 'encouraged/invited' to join a related site/service (sic) called Twonky – which purports to allow you to stream all your entertainment type content to all your devices – and get new content from their site(s). A sort of Airplay I assumed, made interesting by being useable on less than pretty new Macs!
Big snag is that their privacy policy wants to trawl your computer to use your contacts, your internet history, current and future activity, your private content etc etc – and whose terms allow them to use this gold in almost any way you can imagine – and some you did not know could exist – and, not content with that, to allow as yet unborn reasons and claims on your privacy and content to be permitted at their discretion with the very minimum of flimsy defences for the 'user'.
Donald Rumsfeld himself would be proud to have devised such a policy.
So, not wishing to pay a lawyer to check this out, 'no thanks' – and no thanks – to the bin then – option 2 it was.
Tom Wiseman,
Now seriously, you MUST have read an internet services Terms of Service agreement prior to now. Any service that is going to provide you with all sorts of great useful and FREE content, while providing you with this multi-device streaming service, is clearly going to require something in return. Just because we are on the internet, or online, does NOT mean that the expression, "You don't get SOMEthing for NOthing" is rendered invalid and obsolete.
Don't say bad things about Donald Rumsfeld, not in this regard! Facebook and many other social networking services release every piece of their users' personal information to any teenager in Australia, India or Kansas who wants to develop third-party app's. The U.S. government (or any other government, for that matter), needed to file subpoena's in order to get the same level of access! That was a ridiculous situation.
True, things seem to have changed. One aspect seems to be less formalized government access to information, which is ominous. Maybe Facebook et. al. will be more careful with users' private information. Unfortunately, the negative impact on our 4th Amendment constitutional rights will remain, and in ways that are difficult to anticipate.
I would not mind if they set it to on and then announced when you next logged in that there is this feature and it is turned on by default, go here to change the settings…but if they turn it on and never make it public that they did, then that is despicable.
They did announce it to everyone on the top of the homepage pretty clearly.
Not for me they didn't.
They have, however, bugged me to re-enable it since I turned it off. 😦
I strongly dislike any program that likes to share my "stuff" that I didn't ask for.
I've noticed the Yahoo FB application and some others started sharing the articles I had been reading too.
Thanks for the write-up. I thought they said adult content never has views and that you'd only be listed if you were already publicly following the topics on those example questions, e.g. Bad Breath and Necrophilia. Do you know if that's true?
One has to expect to be watched, followed, traced, and all without privacy and with the knowledge that it's all shared somewhere. We are not people when on the Internet; we are a statistic.
People sign up somewhere and expect a lot of care, consideration, and privacy, We should expect the opposite. If there is something we don't want others to know, do not pot it up on the 'net. If we don't want people to know what we search for, view, or visit, then avoid places that allow such offerings.
It's that simple really. Or better still, avoid social networks.
Gotta agree with Internaut- social Networks are minefield for the uninitiated and even , in some instances for the savvy folk. Anything that underhandedly changes the rules is a unethical, probabaly illegal and certainly dangerous to users.
My thoughts – ditch this one and look long and hard at Facebook ,Twitter et al – they are all fodder for hackers , spammers and provide all sorts of information that can be used by the site operators for their own dubious ends.
There’s no purpose in announcing what they’ve done, after the fact. They could have just as easily announced the feature before hand, including mentioning the opt-in option.
The way they handled it was inexcusable.
People can say they don’t care if others know what they’ve read, but it’s nobody’s business unless you, yourself, want it to be.
I don't want anyone checking my contact list, and that is what Quora is asking me to allow.
I can get whatever information they have elsewhere or live without it.
As a web publisher, I occasionally google my name, and surprise, surprise, the #1 spot on google was some site called Quora. I thought this was odd, because for a couple weeks, I had been getting notices that my facebook friends were “following me on Quora”.
Now, I’m very VERY particular about what sites I join, and NEVER use my facebook to join anything. On the Quora profile was a Christmas themed profile picture I used for about 2 weeks on facebook, and a list of interests seemingly scraped at random from my facebook like list. My facebook privacy settings are set to the highest levels.
I asked my friends who were “following me” and all 11 of them said they had not selected to follow me at all, 4 of them didn’t even know what Quora was. Only 2 of them were active users.
I deactivated the profile in the control panel, which was somehow linked to my facebook ID, removed the facebook ID sharing options, changed the profile picture to “f*ck quora” and my interests to the same, unfollowed the people it had started following for me, and have written them over a dozen times to their privacy@quora.com to DELETE the account, and STILL, the site came up for #1 google result for my name.
#1 without any activity and ZERO backlinks.
So I wrote an abuse complaint to google, and within a week the search result went down to the third page, but is still online, even with the “do not show to search engines” option clicked.
Today, I received an email “weekly digest” from Quora, and for the 7th time, clicked the “do not send me weekly digests” link and was told that no more digests would be sent to the email I ONLY use for facebook account login.
Quora is the spammiest, scammiest social site out there and I sincerely hope they go under soon, as hopefully the best way to get my profile finally removed.
QUORA SUCKS.
I just found Quora via a google search (on a Java topic). I was quite surprised to be presented with a "you shall not proceed unless and until you sign up with your google account or your facebook account" notice. Not in the least interested in doing so I clicked the "sign up using google" option just to see what blood they wanted. Well, it was no surprise perhaps to see they wanted to view my email address, and "View basic information about your account". Ah, I wonder what that means? So I have to click the tiny little "i" to the right-hand side to divine just what is meant by "basic information". Turns out, basic information is:
View your NAME, public profile URL, and PHOTO
View your gender and BIRTHDATE
View your COUNTRY, language, and timezone
Eh, I don't THINK so.
When you google something on the internet and a link is asking you all the questions in the comments above DON”T join. Everything you google has a 99% chance of being on another site. Remember “If it sounds too good to be true…It usually is.”
I actually just hit my first Quora link, via Google, and it made me laugh. Who is stupid enough to use them? It’s guaranteed that the answers are in other Google hits. …and any “experts” who want their commentary locked up behind this sort of a firewall are people whose opinions I can do without. …Who *started* this blitering idiocy?
Oh. “Ex-Facebook employees.” …Well, that’s one less mystery, isn’t it…
The other day I got one of the usual email digests from Quora and clicked on the message and it automatically opened a new tab and… I was automatically signed in to Quora. Without using my Quora password. And it was the first time I had signed in in a few weeks. And I clear my cookies and other history every day. So how did they manage to sign me in without me entering my password?
I checked my Quora account info and could not find the “View” option. My account did have a list of “Activities” which included anything I had posted or voted on. But not anything I had just looked at/read.
I checked another poster’s profile to see if this info was shown to the public. Sure enough there it was.
Now, this stuff is all gleanable from the forum posts, but it would take some searching. I don’t find any way not allow it from being listed on one’s profile.
Has the “View” option been discontinued?
NO help or contact info. Tried oit today. You can opt out of everything except one. Asks for google contacts permission, says you can deny it at google, but at google for quorua you actually do not get that option. On Quora account you cannot edit your handle. When I comment my handke is listed repeated… looks like sloppy coding. Quora is very slow to load… on fast devices. Plus the observations noted by others here. Weird. Probably designed as a business to be sold to data scrapers market data miners later. Going to just delete my account there. Reddit so much nicer.
Good luck with that… I can’t delete it.
Seriously, how do you get rid of this Quora showing up everywhere I surf. I have never intentionally signed up for a Quora Account, but I can’t delete it because I don’t have a password to log in to delete the account!!! I wouldn’t use this program or Malware or whatever it is for any reason.
To be brutally honest, I think anyone who cares about this sort of thing is pretty creepy themselves. Who the hell would care about this sort of petty stuff? We’re all nobodies, nobody cares about whether you were abused,as a child had bad breath or visit porn sites. It can be fun to guess ( I had 2 of those three, can you guess which ones?) but really, it isn’t some big weird Big Brother deal.
OTH “Big sister” Quora cares, Along with the usual crap, I’ve seen real people with real problems open up there and get real help, . I’ve posted my own problems up anonymously, and got help. Its time to grow up;, transparency is the only way to go, see whats happened with the \Panama Papers? Does anyone really think it has done anything but good to get this stuff out in the open?.
The world is already populated by a species which consumes too much or everything, is incapable of self control and threatens to wipe out most higher life on earth through accident or stupidity. And you’re worried about whether someone knows about your acne?. You lot think “personal privacy” is a big deal? Wake up!
Get your heads out of your assholes and get to work, there’s a lot to do to get these real problems this stuff sorted and very little time..
Alan Sloan – on Quora, happy to follow up there.
Is it still active ? The view option ?
Nope. 12.31.2016
Quora wants to view and manage my contacts. Never agree to this. Quora is not very good now anyway.
Quora is a weird site, it blocks what you are reading and ask for a password and it does not provide a facebook plug in. I hope that this does not become a trend, sites like this needs to die.
I will NEVER bother with Quora again. Once I realized I had to use my actual first and last name to sign up I was done. I tried to delete my account, however, after deleting it numerous times it never signed me out, nor actually deleted my account. I thought about trying to sign back up and just use a fake name; however, then their ‘prove you are not a robot – captca (whatever it is called) drone went batshit and was forcing me to answer picture puzzle questions over and over and over …. I realized it was 100% not worth the hassle. I will skip over any Quora hits I see going forward.
How STUPID of a site to force people to use their real names. You know the majority will just use a fake one, so why bother? People do not want their personal information out there to be searched for, which is why I have a few names I use when I reply to anything. I avoid Facebook like the plague since they too force you to use your actual name. So any articles or blogs I read where the comment section is a Facebook reply section has always been out of the question for me. Never link up or reply via Facebook.
Why are these websites trying to force people to violate their own personal privacy? My next step is to sign up for a VPN to route all my traffic through. I am not going to be monitored by anyone for any reason online. It’s akin to walking down the road in a city’s downtown area with a giant placard hanging off your back with your name, age, address, marital status, etc ….. why would ANYONE want to subject themselves to that?
I never applied to this app, recently popped up in my gmail, and am not interested in their submissions, they are crap like Facebook and make it impossible to get out off, and feeding one trivial garbage, plus passing on what one reads? They invaded my privacy, whatever that now is, they are invasive trash!
Is the view option still active? When was it deactivated if not active or is there any way we can deactivate quora from showing others what we read.
Graham….so how does Quora finance its operations? Mining user information in profiles.
I have just been “banned from comments” for not using my “real name”…which goes against all my rules for being online. I dont do F/book or the other social media…I used to do chatrooms, but never revealed my identity, using nicknames etc…neither used photos,,,,aware of facial recognition software,,,,however, I am not evil, or have never trolled.
Quora, has been a wonderful positive motivational factor for me to dive even deeper into Tor and Dark Net alternatives. Sitting at home Xmas Day, alone, like a good nerd. Up pops Quora with: “Do you think psychopaths feel emotions for certain people” that was what made me uncover just how creepy they really are. And what about that deletion process. Gotta Luv ’em.