Wait, what? Twitter is a terrorist?

Filed Under: Featured, Law & order, Twitter

Foreign Policy magazine ran an article this week that positions Twitter as a recruiter for Al-Qaeda:

There's a new jihadist recruiter on the Internet. Based in San Francisco and backed by a multimillion dollar bankroll, the recruiter orchestrates thousands of introductions every day, connecting people at risk of radicalization with extremist clerics and terrorist propagandists - even facilitating online meetings with hardcore al Qaeda members.

The recruiter is Twitter, and it's shaking up the world of online radicalization in ways both large and small.

This is ridiculous on its face, of course. Twitter is no more an Al-Qaeda recruiter than Craigslist is a pimp.

Foreign Policy logoYes, terrorists use Twitter as a recruiting tool, and if the author of the article is to be believed, it works well. But Twitter also works well for organizing protests against totalitarian regimes, discussing the latest security topic, immersing yourself in popular culture and sharing a link to your favorite cat video.

The real shame here is that the article contains some interesting content about how terrorists are using Twitter, and how it's changing the dialog within jihadist circles. That's fascinating stuff!

But it seems to me that the alarmist tone and the attribution of the recruiting behavior to Twitter - rather than to the recruiters that have found Twitter useful - moves the piece from informative to inexcusable.

The article also fails to acknowledge one really big national security advantage to this Twitterified recruiting activity: intelligence gathering.

It's no stretch at all to assume that the National Security Agency, as well as the rest of the US three-letter agencies and similar around the world, are happily using social network analysis, data mining and security letters to gain insight into the comings and goings of emerging terrorist organizations.

Wouldn't we rather have these conversations happening in plain sight on Twitter than on some private, encrypted network, or — even worse — off the grid entirely?

TwitterBut, let's face it, the article stopped being about national security as soon as it attributed the fault for how a tool is used to the tool itself.

Twitter isn't "spoon-feeding encouragement to potentially violent users" just because its algorithms point out connections between users. Expecting Twitter to use those algorithms, which identify possible overlapping interests, to censor its users or steer them away from terrorism demonstrates a certain naivety about how social media works.

If you use Twitter or other social media, this should serve as a reminder that people will inevitably draw inferences - no matter how misguided - about you based on who you follow, friend or add to your circles.

As always, it’s helpful to be vigilant about applying privacy settings and deciding what you post, where you post it and with whom you share it.

, ,

You might like

3 Responses to Wait, what? Twitter is a terrorist?

  1. Freida Gray · 743 days ago

    Did Twitter recently refuse an NSA request for all of it's user data ?Apparently if you refuse to "cooperate" with them they'll label you as a terrorist.

  2. Snertly · 740 days ago

    Obviously written languages are just thinly disguised ploys for releasing data that causes a variety of national interests to be self-embarrassed.

    Governments will NOT BE SAFE until all citizens' abilities to read and write are under the strictest possible control.

  3. Anonymous · 480 days ago

    ain't freedom of speech wonderful. the bginning of the internet was the glory days of communication anarchy that we'll never see again. and let me say hello to the NSA while i'm at it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

About the author

Maxim is a technologist and educator who works in product marketing at Sophos. He is a board member and former executive director of StopBadware. He lives outside Boston and has an unhealthy love of dessert.