As of Monday, all was well in Pakistan’s Ayub National Park, at least as far as Google Maps was concerned, which was showing it as a verdant green swath of pixels.
It was a nice change from the image of Google’s Android icon peeing on an Apple logo: an image that a map prankster uploaded to Google Maps and which had stayed up for an undetermined time.
Google apologized for the inappropriate content in a statement emailed to the Washington Post last week.
The paper quoted the statement from Google’s Mara Harris:
We're sorry for this inappropriate user-created content; we're working to remove it quickly. We also learn from these issues, and we're constantly improving how we detect, prevent and handle bad edits.
Harris told the Washington Post that the vast majority of users who edit Google Maps provide “great contributions.”
There’s the vast majority, and then there’s “nitricboy“, whose user profile page on Map Maker shows that he made the edits to Google Maps last week.
Contributors to a Hacker News thread on nitricboy point to his other stunts, including a giant smiley face drawn onto Islamabad, as well as a Skype logo that apparently no longer appears on Google Maps.
The bladder-voiding Android image was submitted as a park, located on the outskirts of Rawalpindi, a Pakistani city 10 miles southwest of Islamabad.
Such jokey edits are submitted via Google’s Map Maker: a service the company introduced in 2008 that lets users worldwide upload new data to the company’s online mapping service.
Opening up map-making to crowdsourcing has helped Google to fill in the details of its maps, particularly in areas where governments restrict distribution of such data in what are often less-developed regions.
Contributions from new users are moderated by more experienced users, or Google reviewers, to ensure quality and prevent vandalism such as the peeing bot or the giant cat that sprawled over Auckland’s Hobson Bay Walkway in October.
But while crowdsourcing opens up map making to any and all comers, it’s also prone to being abused by users who, according to Tech Crunch, create additional accounts in order to “approve” their own adolescent edits.
Alternatively sometimes users approve the edits because they’re in on the joke or would like to be in on the joke.
Map Maker isn’t the only way to screw around with Google Maps.
Earlier this month, somebody set up a joke business on the maps service. It was purportedly a snowboarding shop called “Edwards Snow Den,” located at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue – an address otherwise known as the White House.
It’s since been wiped away, but the Washington Post reported that the Google Plus listing for the shop posted hours – open daily from 5 am until 11 pm – and a Washington state phone number that was leading to a busy signal.
Those pranks aren’t hard to pull.
Because Google relies so heavily on user-submitted content, it’s easy to make a listing for “Edwards Snow Den” at a different address and then submit an address change for 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue.
Or, for that matter, a listing for “freddy fazbear pizza”, which was located within the building that houses the US Department of the Treasury. (It no longer appears there as of Monday).
As the newspaper notes, this was apparently an allusion to the Freddy Fazbear horror video game: one in which the animatronic, homicidal bear roams a pizza parlor after hours, murderously stuffing humans into a Freddy Fazbear suit.
Google said last week that it is – as always – trying to figure out how to handle the complex issue of spam, including tweaking its systems to improve how they prevent, detect and take down incorrect edits.
One comment on “Google blushes over Google Maps showing Android icon urinating on Apple icon”
Many years ago, I lived near a government facility in the UK that manufactured bombs. Except it was not on the map because the main source of mapping information (the Ordnance Survey, ironic in itself) apparently thought that if it wasn’t on the map, the Russians would not know it was there.
So we have moved from maps that are incorrect by government subtraction to maps that are incorrect by user addition.
On the face of it, this is just a prank. But then consider that Google maps is used for navigation and potentially in autonomous vehicles and it is possible to conclude that there are potentially serious security implications.
Close to where I live is a wonderful big sign that says “Satnav WRONG. Do not drive past this sign; it leads nowhere and there is nowhere to turn round”. The second part is roughly what it says from memory – it is on the Parrett Trail near Bridgwater (the place of the great floods of the 2013-4 winter) and past the sign you are on a narrow track that leads along the riverbank for farmers and walkers. Satnavs routed so many people down it who got stuck that the sign had to be erected (does everyone just follow their Satnavs?).